Showing posts with label contraction. Show all posts
Showing posts with label contraction. Show all posts

Sunday, January 11, 2009

Warren Buffet, Preds fan.

"Be fearful when others are greedy. Be greedy when others are fearful." -- Warren Buffett, world's smartest investor.

Sign of the times: On Frozen Blog recounts the latest developments in the never-ending prattle over NHL relocation, expansion and/or contraction. As usual, pundits and "insiders" from the Great White North insist that any (or, in their best-case fantasies, every single one) of the Sunbelt franchises could make the decision to cut their financial losses and head northward to a "traditional" market. Presumably, this would involve renaming the team the "Jets" and signing Teemu Selanne.



In previous seasons, this cause celebre was bound up in a pointless mish-mash of discussion having to do with old-time rivalries, talent dilution and market demographics. The theory went something like this: hockey belongs in places where you might die of hypothermia.

But the market crash has blown this concept into epic proportions, with pundits coming out of the woodwork to speculate that it is now literally impossible for the NHL to sell its product in such hockey-wastelands as Atlanta and Miami. Here's the doomsday equation:
1) Hard-hit areas such as Florida cannot support a team with gate revenues.
2) Hard-hit ownership groups can no longer afford to wait on markets to develop.
3) The values of the American and Canadian dollars have changed drastically this decade.
=
Quotes like the following:
The upside for Canadian fans is that those economic woes could mean another team north of the border as owners look to the game's hotbeds as an economic salve. -- Kevin McGran in the Toronto Star

It's not shocking to see this turn in the discussion, considering there's long been a conservative movement afoot among Canadian fans resentful of the Americanization of the NHL. The economic crisis provides the perfect combination of fear and greed to fuel an argument that the league should simply stop trying to survive in sunny locations, and retract back into its previous strategy of northern-market-saturation.

But let's take a step back from the hysteria and think about this rationally.
-In the past 15 years, two Canadian franchises have relocated (Winnipeg and Quebec) and three more (Ottawa, Calgary and Edmonton) have been on the death-watch for economic reasons.
-In the meantime, two teams in traditional American markets (Pittsburgh and Buffalo) have filed for bankruptcy, while another (Hartford) relocated.
-Furthermore, at least two others (the Islanders and Devils) are failing at the gate but being floated by lucrative dealings on the business side.

So let's not get too hasty about the game's "hotbeds" being a magic bullet for the NHL's revenue problems.

What we're seeing are short-term answers being proposed for a long-term solution.
Fifteen years ago it seemed like a slam-dunk investment to put a team in the southern United States; and in markets that boasted a competitive team, that investment was fruitful.
Five years ago it seemed that half of the Canadian franchises might be doomed; Finals runs by each of the aggreived franchises put those rumors to rest.
Today it's come full circle -- the Sun Belt is being characterized as barren ground, and Canadian cities as a sure bet, at least until the next market cycle proves all of those assumptions wrong.

"Be fearful when others are greedy. Be greedy when others are fearful."


Just as Bettman's expansion bonanza of the 1990s proved to be a case of too-much-too-soon, it makes little sense to simply slash-and-burn fifteen years of market cultivation in the name of hockey tradition. Atlanta, Phoenix, Tampa and Miami are in the top 16 television markets in the United States; Hamilton, the largest available Canadian market other than Quebec City, is smaller than any of these and shares its television market with Toronto and at-risk Buffalo. Where's the sense in swapping one risky market for another, at an enormous expense?

For once, let's learn from the past. Instead of pursuing the obvious, ill-fated strategy of tagging along behind market predictors and putting teams in today's hot markets, the NHL should take a step back from the current depression and think about where it would like to stand in 20 years. In that time, franchises like Atlanta and Phoenix will surely figure out how to ice a team worth paying for (Step 1: Fire Waddell) and in the meantime they will cultivate a full generation of born-and-bred fans. They might still be the least-dependable American markets, but they'll give the NHL continued national recognition and television coverage instead of allowing it to regress back to a provincial B-sport akin to golf and figure skating.

Stumble Upon Toolbar

Sunday, August 24, 2008

5 Ways I Wouldn't Change the NHL

NHL superblogger Greg Wyskynski (the man behind the excellent, if slightly creepily-named Puck Daddy blog at Yahoo!) never seems to have trouble drumming up conversation, but his "5 Ways I'd Change the NHL" series this August has proved a near-perfect antidote for the summer doldrums. The hockeyblogosphere has lit up to near-seasonlike levels as everyone's brother plays Bettman for a day.

Far be it from me to follow a trend (I'm a blogger, for chrissake... that's not trendy at all. Right?). Here's my little tribute to contrarianism: 5 ways that I think the NHL could kick itself in the nuts by trying a little TOO hard:

1) Overemphasizing fantasy and gambling

One reason that the NHL has remained relatively scandal-free over the past decade is that it generally doesn't share in the Vegas-driven gambling culture. While other leagues scramble to counteract a surge in on- and off-field corruption, the NHL has yet to encounter a serious challenge to the integrity of its product (Sean Avery notwithstanding). And perhaps more importantly, hockeyphiles are almost universally focused on the Stanley Cup as their lone objective -- not just keeping the score close enough to beat the spread.

Fantasy hockey is a great way to increase the engagement of otherwise-casual fans, and should probably marketed more aggressively in order to catch up with other sports. But the NHL is better off because of the distance it keeps from organized gambling; the temptation to "hook" fans (and players) into an addictive and destructive habit shouldn't be taken lightly.

2) Abandoning markets

This one strikes a soft spot for me, because I'm what the NHL execs would consider an "untraditional" fan. I am from a place where 6 inches of snow closes the schools, I am frequently out-skated by toddlers in Sidney Crosby jerseys, and the three closest franchises to my home are considered "problems" by most pundits. But in spite of all that, I have spent more time and money and emotion on the NHL than on all other sports combined. In my small rural community I know at least 2 other diehard households who buy season tickets for a team more than 90 minutes away. I would happily stab Claude Lemieux in the eye if it gave the Bruins a top-10 draft pick.

So be careful what you wish for when the "C" word is brought into the discussion. Contracting teams might be a theoretical quick-fix for an overexpanded league, but it is a scorched-earth option that leaves very few relationships intact. The costs are far higher than the rewards.

3) Pushing too hard for uniformity

If variety is the spice of life, the NHL is a veritable jambalaya. The league has become genuinely international, franchises are scattered from southern Florida to British Columbia, and the players vary from Vogue editors to Mike Ricci. Yet as is always the case in big business, the prevailing winds push toward faceless uniformity. It affects everything from the "arena experience" (which is largely driven by the NBA template in most markets), to rink dimensions, to uniform rules. All of this is to the detriment of a league that thrives on its sense of originality and eccentricity.

So let's loosen up a little and allow teams a little creativity with their in-game experience. Why mandate rink sizes when you can allow each team to choose its own floorplan? Let Detroit have extra-wide ice for its puck-moving defensemen, let the Bruins shrink their ice to favor a defensive game (and bring back memories of the old Garden), let the Pens add a few feet to the neutral zone for their young speedsters. Baseball doesn't seem to suffer from its diversity in playing fields.

Furthermore, let's lose the helmets during shootouts. Let's encourage theatrics which allow the fans to relate to the players. And for god's sake, let's ditch the canned hip-hop and bring back the good old days of the in-house organist. NHL, we just want you to be yourself.

4) Changing more rules

To some degree, rule changes were necessary in the wake of the 1990s. The awful controversies over the Crease Rule... goalies racing down the puck in the corners and shooting it back to the neutral zone... teams icing the puck 4 or 5 times in a row. It gives me a headache to even remember some of those games. But after a certain amount of tinkering has been done, you have to stop and let the product sell itself. The game has twice the "flow" it did 10 years ago, and Keith Tkachuk is no longer the model of a 50-goal scorer. Casual fans, especially those who are just returning to the game after being alienated a few years ago, need to be able to recognize and identify with what's happening on the ice. Diehards need some time to bond with new rituals like the shootout and 4-on-4 overtime. Aside from very small tweaks, such as the size of goalie pads, it's time to leave the game alone for a while.

5) Insisting that something's terribly wrong

Nothing ruins a relationship like insecurity. Instead of admiring the beautiful, you obssess over microscopic flaws. Instead of enjoying yourself, you wonder what you're missing.

The NHL is not perfect, and never will be. In the year 2050 there will still be diving, obstruction, butterfly goalies, and Chris Chelios (specifically, his preserved brain inside a Terminator body). But at its heart the game of hockey is still a beautiful thing to behold, and it always will be.

Stumble Upon Toolbar